Complete 2026 MLB Team Grades: Surprises and Disappointments

The 2026 Major League Baseball season has wrapped up, and comprehensive evaluations of each club's performance have been released. According to ESPN Top, these annual grades provide insight into how well teams performed relative to their expectations over the season. As October approaches, the standings reveal a mix of outcomes across the league. Some teams surprised fans with stellar performances that earned them high marks, while others faced disappointment, resulting in lower grades. Teams that reached the playoffs likely benefitted from consistent play and strategic decisions that paid off. Conversely, those struggling at the bottom of the standings seemed unable to capitalize on opportunities, leading to their lower evaluations. Analysis of individual team performances highlights various factors that contributed to their final grades. Offseason acquisitions, injury management, player development, and coaching strategies were all crucial elements that influenced how well each team matched up against its preseason expectations. Teams that performed well in the playoffs had strong finishes, demonstrating resilience and adaptability in the face of competition. These squads not only showcased their baseball skills but also illustrated effective teamwork and progress throughout the year. On the other side of the spectrum, teams that fell short often dealt with inconsistent batting, pitching issues, or key injuries that hindered their success. Such struggles impacted not just their standings but also their evaluations as they head into the offseason, where changes may be inevitable in an attempt to regroup and improve. As the league gears up for the postseason, the final grades serve as a reminder of the highs and lows experienced during the 2026 season. With each team reflecting on their performance, the offseason promises to be an active period in MLB as franchises analyze their strategies looking forward to the next season.